Correcting the earlier scope-union-only fix. The real damage from a logout→login isn't
just the stored `scope` field — verified via a live token refresh that the stored refresh
token itself had been REPLACED with a base-only one: a plain sign-in requests only
BASE_SCOPES and Google handed back a fresh base-only access+refresh token, which
_store_token adopted verbatim, destroying the read/write grant (the old refresh token
stays valid on Google's side, so overwriting it is what loses access).
_store_token now detects when an exchange would NARROW our YouTube scopes and, in that
case, keeps the WHOLE existing grant (refresh token, access token, scopes) untouched.
Broader-or-equal exchanges (first grant, read→write upgrade) adopt + union as before.
Unit-verified across base-relogin / upgrade / new-user / base-user cases.
Two user-reported signin bugs:
1) A plain re-login (or logout→login) wiped the user's YouTube grant: login requests
only BASE_SCOPES and Google's returned `scope` can list just those, but _store_token
wrote it verbatim — dropping a previously-granted youtube.readonly/youtube scope, so
can_read flipped to false and the feed demanded a reconnect. The underlying grant
(refresh token) survives such a login, so UNION the scopes instead of narrowing; they
only shrink on full disconnect (purge deletes the token row).
2) Admin 'new access request' email: (a) it named the wrong menu ('Settings → Account'
instead of Users → Access requests); (b) the requester address was invisible so the
'reply reaches them' note looked wrong (Reply-To is in fact set to the requester) —
now spelled out + a deep-link straight to the approve view (?admin=access-requests,
handled in App); (c) it emailed only the static env ADMIN_EMAILS — now notifies the
ACTUAL admins (active role=admin users) unioned with env, so a UI-promoted admin (who
CAN approve — the approve UI is role-gated) is notified too.
Loose ends to finish the auth security round:
- register + password-reset-request had an enumeration TIMING oracle: an already-
registered email skipped the create path (hash + row writes + email scheduling) and
responded measurably faster than a new one. Move the whole lookup+create (register)
and lookup+token+email (reset) into a background task with its own DB session, so the
endpoint returns in the same time for any valid email regardless of whether it exists.
Verified: existing vs new now ~equal (was 34ms vs 82ms on register); accounts/tokens
still created off-path.
- messages_ws re-implemented resolved_user_id's per-tab wallet-gated account resolution.
Generalize resolved_user_id to take any HTTPConnection (Request OR WebSocket) and call
it from the WS — one shared, wallet-gated resolution. Behavior-identical (unit-checked).
Post-review hardening (both fail-safe, not bugs):
- _client_ip normalizes IPs via ipaddress and unwraps IPv4-mapped IPv6, so a plain
TRUSTED_PROXY_IPS=10.10.0.1 also matches a peer surfaced as ::ffff:10.10.0.1 (a
Docker/IPv6 self-host footgun that would otherwise silently collapse everyone into
one rate-limit bucket).
- entrypoint.sh + _client_ip docstring: explicit warning never to add uvicorn
--proxy-headers, which would rewrite request.client from the forgeable XFF and defeat
the trust check.
_client_ip trusted the first X-Forwarded-For hop unconditionally, so anyone able to
reach the app port could forge XFF and dodge the login/register/reset/demo rate limits.
Now trust XFF ONLY when the request's socket peer is a configured reverse proxy
(settings.trusted_proxy_ips, e.g. the VPS Caddy's WireGuard peer IP), and take the
RIGHTMOST entry — the client our proxy actually saw and appended, immune to a client
pre-seeding a fake XFF. A request from any other peer (hitting the port directly) is
keyed on its real socket IP, so XFF can't be forged to bypass the limits.
New TRUSTED_PROXY_IPS env (empty default = no proxy, use the direct peer). Documented in
.env.example, docs/self-hosting.md, README. Unit-verified against spoof-through-proxy and
direct-bypass cases.
Adversarial re-review of the session-epoch work surfaced:
- WS auth (messages_ws) skipped the epoch check, so a revoked-but-unexpired cookie
could still open the live push channel after a reset/logout-others. Now mirrors
current_user: loads the user once, rejects a stale-epoch cookie before connecting.
- set_password + logout_others re-stamped the cookie BEFORE db.commit(); a failed
commit would strand the current session at a newer epoch than the DB and wrongly
401 it. Commit first, then re-stamp.
- Welcome verify effect could double-POST the single-use token (StrictMode/remount)
and flip the banner to a false 'invalid'. Fire-once useRef guard.
Left as-is (low value, documented): the Plex image proxy authenticates without a DB
load / epoch check (poster/art fetches only); adding one would cost a DB hit per image.
Signed client-side session cookies had no server-side kill switch: logout + password
reset couldn't evict a stolen/copied cookie (valid until expiry). Add User.session_epoch
(migration 0053), record it in the cookie at every login, and reject in current_user any
cookie whose recorded epoch is behind the account's current one.
- Bump the epoch on: password reset (kills ALL sessions — a reset is a compromise response),
password change + a new 'Log out other sessions' action (both re-stamp the CURRENT cookie
so the caller stays signed in, evicting only the others).
- Per-account epoch map in the session so one account's revocation doesn't evict the other
signed-in accounts in the same browser wallet.
- Missing epoch (pre-SA4 cookie) is treated as 0, so the first bump revokes grandfathered
sessions too.
- New POST /auth/logout-others + a Settings → Account 'Active sessions' button (trilingual).
Secret email tokens now ride the URL fragment (#reset=/#verify=), never the query
(?reset=/?token=): a fragment isn't sent to the server, so the token can't leak into
proxy/access logs or a Referer header.
- Reset: link → /#reset=; the SPA reads the token from location.hash and POSTs it
(unchanged /password-reset/confirm).
- Verify: link → /#verify=; new POST /auth/verify (token in body). The legacy GET
/auth/verify?token= is kept so pre-deploy emails in flight still work until they
expire. The SPA reads the fragment token, POSTs it, shows ok/invalid.
- Welcome: read secret tokens from the fragment, status flags from the query; strip
both after capture so nothing lingers in history.
From the auth /security-review (contained fixes; architectural SA3 proxy-trust +
SA4 session-revocation deferred to the user):
- SB1: encrypt the OAuth access_token at rest (was plaintext while refresh_token
was encrypted) — a ~1h Google bearer credential. New security.decrypt_optional()
falls back to a refresh for legacy plaintext tokens; column is unbounded String.
E2E-verified: token refreshed → stored as Fernet ciphertext → 319-subscription
YouTube sync succeeded.
- SA5: password_login is no longer a timing/enumeration oracle — it always runs
argon2 (against a decoy hash for unknown/passwordless emails), so response time
can't reveal whether an account exists.
- SB2: Google login only ADOPTS+activates a pre-existing password account when
Google actually attests email_verified (defense-in-depth against takeover); and
the email sync won't overwrite with a value another account owns (avoids a 500).
- demo_login clears the wallet first (demo can't switch to / act as a real account
via the multi-account header); switch_account rejects a suspended target (which
would otherwise clear the whole session on the next request).
Re-review clean; ruff clean; localdev boots; YouTube auth path E2E-verified.
The logged-out landing probed /api/me, which 401'd, and the browser logs every
non-2xx fetch as a console error regardless of how the app handles it. The
bootstrap probe now returns 200 with {authenticated:false} via a new
optional_current_user dependency; api.me() maps that to null. The render gate
treats no-data as 'signed out' -> the landing, and a thrown error as a real
network/5xx failure. Other protected endpoints still 401, so mid-session expiry
is still caught by the global handler. Lighthouse (dev): Best Practices 96->100.
A plain <a> file download can't send the X-Siftlode-Account header, so current_user resolved
it to the session-default account — 404 'Unknown download' when the tab acts as a non-default
wallet account that owns the file. resolved_user_id now also honours a ?account= query param
(the same wallet-gated selection the WebSocket already uses), and downloadFileUrl appends the
active account id. Verified: default account -> 404, ?account=<owner> -> 206 with the right
Content-Disposition.
Two tabs in one browser can now run two different signed-in accounts at once.
- The signed session cookie stays the browser's account WALLET (account_ids). Which account a
given tab acts as is a per-tab choice held in sessionStorage and sent per-request via the
X-Siftlode-Account header; current_user honours it only for an account already in the wallet,
without mutating the cookie's default account. Switching accounts sets the header + reloads
THIS tab only, instead of the old cookie-wide switch that changed every tab.
- WebSocket can't send headers, so the per-tab account rides in the ?account= query param
(validated against the wallet).
- Logout is per-tab aware: it signs the requesting tab's active account out of the wallet
(promoting a new default only if the removed one was the default), and the tab drops its
override. A stale per-tab header account 401s just that tab instead of clearing the session.
- Serve index.html with Cache-Control: no-cache so a deploy's new hashed bundle is picked up
immediately instead of the browser running a heuristically-cached stale index.html.
- Remove owner-specific / legacy deploy files (home/prod/server compose, deploy/).
The home compose stays as a local untracked file for the maintainer's own deploy.
- Genericise infra-specific code comments (egress-proxy examples) to neutral wording.
- Replace the hardcoded contact email on the legal pages with the instance operator's
configured admin email, served via the public /auth/config and shown with a neutral
fallback — so each self-hosted instance shows its own contact.
- Rewrite README for the current app + a copy-paste self-hosting quick start (prebuilt
image + first-run wizard) with a build-from-source alternative; tidy .env.example.
- app/utils.py: shared valid_email() + now_utc() (one email regex, was duplicated
in auth.py and admin.py with a looser "@"-in check elsewhere).
- security.hash_token(): one SHA-256 token hasher (was duplicated in auth.py + state.py).
- auth.admin_user dependency + count_admins() helper, replacing the inline role
checks and the last-admin count query repeated across admin.py/me.py/tags.py.
Replace the leftover 'subfeed' name across logger names + log_config,
frontend localStorage keys, Postgres user/db/volume defaults in the
compose files, .env.example, config.py, backup/restore scripts and the
README. Pure rename; no behavioural change. localStorage keys move from
subfeed.* to siftlode.* (one-time UI-state reset is acceptable).
- Build the Google OAuth client lazily from sysconfig (DB override, env fallback) and re-register
when the credentials change, so the install wizard / admin can set them without a restart.
- New 'google' config group (google_client_id/secret, encrypted) on the Configuration page; the
token-refresh reads the creds the same way.
- Public GET /auth/config exposes google_enabled; the login page hides 'Continue with Google'
when Google OAuth isn't configured (email+password still works).
- Link a Google account to a password account, and adopt the Google identity onto a matching
email account instead of 500ing on a duplicate; set or change a password from Settings.
- Expose has_google/has_password on /api/me for the Sign-in methods UI.
- Mark Google logins email-verified (backfill existing rows, migration 0024); stop a routine
login from clobbering an admin-assigned role (env ADMIN_EMAILS stays the bootstrap admin).
- Suspension login-gates (password + Google callback + current_user) with a rate-limited
'suspended' notice; shared purge_user (cascade delete + access-request cleanup + Google-grant
revoke) behind self- and admin-deletion; single app_base source for user-facing email links.
Add email+password auth alongside Google: argon2id hashing; users gains
password_hash/email_verified/is_active and google_sub becomes nullable (migration
0022); a single-use, hashed auth_tokens table for email verification + password
reset. Registration creates a pending (inactive, unverified) account + an access
request; sign-in needs verified email AND admin approval. Anti-enumeration: uniform
register/login/reset responses (a correct-password owner still gets a specific
pending reason). allow_registration flag (DB-tunable). Admin users-list + role
endpoint (guards: not self, not demo, not the last admin); approving access (or a
manual whitelist add) now activates the matching pending account. current_user
rejects deactivated accounts. Verified end-to-end via curl + DB.
The shared demo account no longer hits YouTube affordances: the onboarding
wizard never opens (or renders) for it, the empty-feed prompt nudges into
the shared library instead of the connect wizard, and the browser-facing
/auth/upgrade redirects the demo home instead of returning a raw 403 JSON.
Whitelisted emails enter the shared demo user via /auth/demo (lazily
created, no OAuth token/scope), rate-limited per IP and answering
uniformly so it can't be hammered as an enumeration oracle. Add a
require_human dependency that blocks the demo account from quota-spending
sync endpoints and the OAuth upgrade flow, and surface is_demo on /api/me.
Sessions created before multi-session existed had no account_ids, so adding a second
account left the first one (e.g. the long-lived session) absent from the switcher.
current_user now ensures the active user_id is always present in account_ids, so the
switch list is never missing the account you're using.
Track every account that completes OAuth in a browser session (session 'account_ids',
~14-day cookie), so the user can switch between them without another Google round-trip.
New GET /api/me/accounts (switchable accounts, active flagged) and POST /api/me/switch
(guarded: target must be in the session list — proof it signed in here — and re-checked
against is_allowed in case the invite was revoked). Logout now signs out the active
account and falls back to the most recent remaining one, else clears the session. UI: the
account popover lists the other signed-in accounts (click to switch, reloads) plus an
'Add another account' action (-> /auth/login, which uses prompt=select_account).
Trilingual. Third step of Epic N.
Set up react-i18next with locale files auto-loaded per area (Vite glob), a compact
LanguageSwitcher, and language as a server-persisted preference (preferences.language)
mirrored to localStorage. On first login the default UI language is guessed from the
Google-reported locale (hu/en/de, else English). vite-env.d.ts types the build-time env.
- requirements: cryptography >=46.0.7 (was pinned <46, which excluded the fix for
the CVEs pip-audit flagged in our Fernet/crypto library). pip-audit now clean.
- Dockerfile: upgrade pip before installing deps (patches installer-level CVEs).
- auth: /auth/upgrade now defaults to the least-privileged read scope; only an
explicit access=write requests the write scope.
Base login now requests only openid/email/profile (non-sensitive), so a new user
gets a clean Google consent with no "unverified app" warning and no 7-day refresh
token expiry. YouTube read (youtube.readonly) and write (youtube) are granted later
by the onboarding wizard via a parameterized /auth/upgrade?access=read|write.
Security fixes folded in from the baseline audit:
- config: refuse to boot in production (https OAUTH_REDIRECT_URL) with the
placeholder/short SECRET_KEY or a missing TOKEN_ENCRYPTION_KEY, closing a
session-forgery / admin-impersonation hole.
- main: mark the session cookie Secure when served over HTTPS.
- me: expose can_read; sync/subscriptions returns a friendly 403 (not a 500)
until YouTube read access is granted.
Move the access whitelist from the ALLOWED_EMAILS env var into a DB Invite table
(env kept as bootstrap fallback), and add a self-service request + admin approval
flow with fail-soft email.
- models: Invite(email, status pending|approved|denied, requested_at, decided_*)
- migration 0008: invites table; seed env ALLOWED_EMAILS u ADMIN_EMAILS as approved
- auth: is_allowed() (DB-first, env fallback); a denied Google login records a pending
request and bounces to /?access=requested instead of a raw 403; public POST
/auth/request-access; upsert is idempotent so repeats don't re-spam admins
- routes/admin.py (admin-only): list/approve/deny invites + manual add
- email.py: smtplib + Gmail App Password, fail-soft (skips if SMTP unset)
- /api/me exposes pending_invites; config + .env.example gain SMTP_*
- UI: Login 'Request access' form + access=requested/denied handling; Settings ->
Access requests (approve/deny + add); admin nudge toast on pending requests
Verified locally: request-access creates a pending invite and emails the admin;
seed approved npeter83; guinea-pig yt.trash2023 denied until approved.
- uvicorn --log-config (log_config.json): timestamped formatters for uvicorn
access/error and the app's own "subfeed" loggers (ms precision)
- Log key activity: startup/shutdown, login/denied, token refresh, YouTube API
errors, subscription imports, sync pause/resume
- Background sync jobs no longer swallow errors silently — failures in RSS poll,
backfill, enrichment, autotag and resync are logged with tracebacks
- Shorts: confirm via youtube.com/shorts/<id> probe (SOCS cookie bypasses the
consent redirect) instead of a 60s heuristic; concurrent probing, shorts_probed
flag, scheduled refinement (migration 0005)
- Search: match title + channel name only (descriptions caused noisy results)
- Faceted tag filtering: AND across categories (language AND topic narrows),
OR within a category; any/all toggle applies to topics
- Language detection: majority vote over individual titles (fixes misdetections
like multipoleguy -> English; drops bogus Polish/Romanian)
- Login: drop forced consent so returning sign-in is quick (select_account)
- Feed cards: clickable channel name (opens channel), persistent saved badge,
undo toast on hide, Hidden view to restore; tag chips show counts in tooltip
- docker-compose with Postgres 16 + slim Python API image
- FastAPI app with session middleware, health endpoint, static login page
- Google OAuth (Authlib) with email invite-list whitelist; admin role support
- User + OAuthToken models; refresh tokens encrypted at rest (Fernet)
- Alembic migrations, run automatically on container startup
- Postgres backup/restore scripts for portability between machines
